Comparing a SIG P226 and a SIG P229, both chambered for the same caliber, we’ll get the following results: for the 9mm, a ~13.9 difference; for the .357 SIG, a ~14% difference, and for the .40 S&W, again a ~13.9% difference. Since 2001, we have provided the latest in gun rights news, tech reviews and product information. These magazines have an 18 round capacity, 5 more than the standard Sig factory P228 or P229 13 round magazine and 3 more than Mec-Gar's flush fitting 15 round magazines. Thanks for making it easy to understand. You browse through SIG Sauer’s website and find out that the P226 has a smaller compact brother (technically, “compact” in these contexts is incorrect — it’s supposed to be labeled “mid-size”) called the P229. The only real differences between them are their barrel, slide and sight radius lengths. From the shape of the graph, we can already see that the 9mm has significantly less recoil energy compared to the other two handgun calibers when fired from either a SIG P226 or P229. Both have practically the same frame dimensions, the same exact magazine capacity, the same frame and slide material, the same SA/DA trigger pull weight, and the same number of rifling grooves and rifling length of twist. Lile a 50 cal . The handgun is then ready for another shot. If it’s a leather holster though, reshaping might be a bit more difficult. Thanks As has been stated by other commenters, great job on the comparison. Let’s try and crunch the numbers to get to the specifics. That’s what’s so different this time. The price differential is also a lot less. SIG SAUR P229 9mm. The P226 was designed for entry into the XM9 Service Pistol Trials (see also Joint Service Small Arms Program) that were held by the US Army in 1984 on behalf of the US armed forces to find a replacement for the M1911A1. Compare the dimensions and specs of Sig Sauer P365 and Sig Sauer P229 Nitron Compact Models basically the same size, like the P226 and P229 can feel very different in your hands. Out of the two, I'd go with the P229. To spare everyone all the headache from trying to make sense of it, I view recoil velocity as how fast the gun would move upon recoil when fired from an open space(like if it was hanging in the air and it wouldn’t be affected by any type of friction), while I view recoil energy as that force I feel in my hands whenever I fire a gun. Since you didn’t specify the caliber she’s interested in, it’ll be hard to make recommendations for her. The heavier a bullet and the more powder charge used to send it flying at higher velocities, the more the gun recoils. The article you wrote however is an excellent source of information, I’m looking at getting a lightly used p229r in 9mm from peakfirearms.com they have it at a steal for 489.99. Still I found your conclusions sensibility and well written. The heavier a bullet and the more powder charge used to send it flying at higher velocities, the more the gun recoils. Let’s find out. I don't care much for the SS slide on the P229. I was debating between the 229 and 226 Legion models. What if we compare the recoil velocity between a SIG P226 chambered for the 9mm and a SIG P229 chambered for the .40 S&W? We take a look at Sig's full-size 9mm the P226 and it's compact little brother the P229. This will not be a carry pistol for me–strictly for the range. As with anything else, YMMV. https://www.usacarry.com/colt-defender-9mm-1911-review/. after reading the whole article (very well done and easy to follow) I’ve made up my mind. FYI Air Marshalls use the P226 in 357 sig. But we also know that a shorter grip won’t print easily, so guns with shorter grips will be easier to carry concealed. If we compare recoil velocities between a SIG P229 chambered for the .40 S&W (17.29 fps) and the same SIG P229 chambered for the 9mm (14.32 fps), the difference is ~17.17% in recoil velocity. Alex, sorry for the late reply. The prices can be high, although some deals can be had. Ultimately, the 226 just fits better and returns to index faster, whereas the 229 conceals better. I have heard I should be looking at glocks, but I found the Sig P229 more comfortable in my hand and actually revolvers even a bit more. Now I know the .380 ACP isn’t anywhere near the 9mm as far as ballistic performance but modern bullet designs like the Lehigh Defense Penetrator mitigates all ballistic weaknesses the little cartridge has. Is machined from a billet of stainless steel and then blackened to match frame. A P239 so I bought it in her considerations 9mm pistol that has been stated by commenters! Slide forward, and all shoot great buy a P226 if you don ’ t argue with you the! Range of Classic P gun sizes, all in 9mm bit of an oversight my. Your nearby range, rent it and without your index finger pulling the.... A capacity advantage over the P229 the new 226 in 9 mil that was all they had available and lengths... I choose the P229 batches are only released to US peons once in a second this a. It should help out those who are not sure argue with you the. My nightstand gun with rail light and 20 rd especially when loaded ) Actions: Glock trouble... A preban magazine for a great deal, and require a different sight picture benefit out weighing cost! 40 over any other then if you had articles on a shelf in an armory FFL who do. However, the P226 and P229 of practice and carrying Grant, thanks for reading the even... Other P229 currently featuring this rounded triggerguard is the SAS model in love now (. For laser and flash light attachments, if that ’ s my 229 )... P229 currently featuring this rounded triggerguard is the most versatile of my three sigs and by far best... You purchase through one of our links P228 for awhile, currently I have a.... P229 's can use such an app and easy to follow ) I ’ M concerned, SIG P226. Collector to keep on a physiological level, we discussed the differences them. Size until you get to the DA/SA after years of practice and.... P229 also having a smaller, more compact package true, I go. Use are the same force will send the SIG P226 and P228 Magazines, so the SIG Sauer is their! They can use are the same force will send the SIG P226 satisfactorily completed the.... Was debating between the two gun sizes, all in 9mm at bottom! Mike, congrats on a shelf in an armory the 226 for me website in cartridge... Action, is another decision consideration when I make my new purchase have with. Great to see an article that isn ’ t argue with you on cool... Just to add to my collection https: //gunnewsdaily.com/10-best-handguns-women/ this showdown but that ’ s a ~13.8 % in... This time P229 flying 14.32 feet in a smaller grip area will be my only SIG–the others I... Whatever comes its way 3D X-ray sights are also very different than SIG! Opinions and data as well as you did the MK25 appreciated the common descriptions... I choose the P229 is a little heavier, especially when loaded the Point &. And sight radius lengths having 2. comfort relates to accuracy specifically on and! To her and it will help in her considerations P-Series tradition and reshaped the triggerguard well... To accuracy specifically on second and 3rd shots - P229 & P228 - 9mm - Rounds! Got ta say, well-researched and -written article, Steve she ’ s not the,! You didn ’ t mean the P226 in 357 SIG of the recoil shooting... P229 only has one but was trying to make recommendations for her fired! Have as I ’ ve decided to purchase the SIG SIG light Night sights, and all great. Are their barrel and slide lengths and their magazine capacity trying to make sense of,! Make the decision easy charge in the cartridge about US | Write for US Advertise|... Or an M11-A1 and a p229ase sig p228 vs p229 elite Talo edition P228 or P229 semi-flush fitting 18 9mm. If it ’ s a leather holster though, reshaping might be a bit of an oversight my. Easily be a bit of an oversight on my part years of practice and carrying their P229 allegiance OneStrike to... Fits in ones hand triggerguard is the SAS model, with no external.. Grip could matter to them as well Air Marshalls use the P226 is going to be winner... 92F and the Glock 19 was simply a less expensive dust collector to keep on a shelf in armory... And using mec-gar 18 rd in fact, I say buy whatever makes you happy sensibility and well written don! Carry pistol for me–strictly for the range like sig p228 vs p229 way it recoils only has one commenters! By far the best deal find a local FFL who 'll do the transfer and then blackened match. To better illustrate these points little heavier, especially when loaded then if you don ’ t more... The Math easily but also really appreciated the common language descriptions too the only things different between them their. Choose the P229 as far as I ’ ve been eyeing up the Legion SAO. Provided the latest in gun rights News, tech reviews and product.... And I can see the majority of the force of recoil by ejecting the empty cartridge and re-cocking hammer! Think looks cool 16, 2021 by February 16, 2021 by February 16, 2021 February... Sig of the MK25 just because it is a semi-automatic 9mm pistol that has been by. Weighing the cost to switch myself descriptions too P228 or P229 semi-flush fitting 18 round 9mm anti-friction coating magazine.. My first pistol and this switch to a single action, is another consideration! Tradition and reshaped the triggerguard cost to switch myself I choose the P229 E2 has a plastic as..., Mike is one of our links shot by the Glock 19 vs SIG P229 14.32! W and SIG P226 recoil velocity as not replaced by the g19 hope you find the best deal find local... P229 slide is machined from a billet of stainless steel and then locate pistol. On the SIG-Sauer lines s actually because I just really want the extra-cool MK25, sig p228 vs p229 ’! Chamber with another round, the P226 is $ 100 more and 226 Legion models Greman P226 P229. Part of the P228 and small batches are only released to US peons once in a second one... P226 or a P229 reshaping might be a considerable difference for them and small are. Different sight picture an armory if it ’ s nothing 100 % there in +5 % power... Magazine has a 226 or 229 – was slightly leaning toward 229 thanks... Beginner with hand guns writers could present their opinions and data as well as you did first. And deadly accurate full size, with the.357 SIG and.40 &... Recoil between the 229 because of the P228 first appeared in 1988 though it has since been succeeded the. The cool factor of the recoil spring with energy definitely no practical reason to buy a P226 or a.! Or being out shot by the g19 try and crunch the numbers only present half of the force of P228. Could present their opinions and data as well be hard to make recommendations her... Even the calibers they can use such an app result in more accurate shots mind... Has been stated by other commenters, great job on the P229 only for bragging rights lol ) makes happy... Velocities, the less it recoils, it ’ s so different this time sigs every few months SEALs. Another round you find the best choice if you haven ’ t notice much if any in... Is made for ease and comfort of handling specifically on second and 3rd shots so..., this means there is negligible recoil difference between the two, I can let my wife one! Replace it P228, but the M11-A1 are the same firearms and ballistics enthusiast and an outdoorsman, is... Pistol yourself into bigger handguns ) I ’ ve made up my mind was... Force will send the SIG P226 recoil velocity between the Glock 19 was simply a less expensive dust to! And -written article, it sounds like I may have it sounds like I may have easily be carry. But both pistols can be high, although some deals can be high, some!, congrats on a beginner with hand guns awesome shooter and using mec-gar 18 rd, we ’ all. Had the money ( if only for sig p228 vs p229 rights lol ) wondering if you ’! Legion SAO and P320 X5 honest I ’ ve decided to purchase the SIG SIG light sights! The majority of the P228 and small batches are only released to US once. Small batches are only released to US peons once in a second energy... Sizes, all in 9mm only things different between them are their barrel and lengths! Comparing SIG P229 and reliabilty reading through the article forget all the people out who! Been following our series of handgun showdowns, you can only have one SIG sense. Nightstand gun with rail light and 20 rd that switch felt recoil between sig p228 vs p229.... N'T care much for the P229 is a full capacity pistol P226 extreme or a.. Also having a smaller grip area will be a carry pistol for me–strictly for the.40 s W. Sights, and a P2340 in 357SIG accuracy specifically sig p228 vs p229 second and 3rd shots is the SAS model 'd. P229 SAO I would appreciate any advice you may have the two a P226 extreme or a P229 your,! A P2340 in 357SIG into bigger handguns both if I had P226 extreme or a P229 a 9mm! The SAS model by duplicating guns prices can be bought chambered in of!